On losing an election, leaving a neighborhood, and the uneasy business of beginning again.
I am writing this sitting on a cardboard box in a house that does not yet feel like home. Around me are the scattered remains of another life: furniture waiting to be arranged, possessions wrapped in paper, the familiar disorder of beginning again. David and I have crossed the river, leaving behind the neighborhood and the routines that had come to define our lives in Portland. Outside, the city continues its ordinary business, indifferent to our departure. Inside, I find myself wondering whether we have simply changed addresses or begun the more complicated process of leaving something behind.
Much has happened since I last wrote. I ran for Portland City Council and lost, an outcome I had anticipated almost from the beginning. I entered the race late, without the machinery, money, or political relationships that serious campaigns require. I knew the odds, although knowing something intellectually is different from experiencing it. Still, I enjoyed the improbable freedom of becoming a candidate, of standing before strangers and speaking without the usual restraints about a city I had watched change, sometimes beyond recognition.
The decision to run had been gathering force for some time. David had been attacked on the street, an experience that altered our sense of safety in ways that statistics and political assurances could not repair. Portland, meanwhile, seemed unable to emerge from the long shadow of the pandemic. Storefronts remained empty, public spaces felt neglected, and the peculiar lethargy that had settled over the city began to feel less like a temporary condition than a permanent state of mind. I had spent years watching these changes from the ground, working on the front lines of the service economy, encountering the city not through policy papers or campaign briefings but through the people who lived and worked in it. I thought that perspective might count for something.
And for a while, it did. There was something unexpectedly liberating about speaking publicly from the authority of one’s own experience. I was not a career politician, nor did I pretend to be. I knew what it meant to work a shift, to depend on a paycheck, to watch a neighborhood deteriorate while officials spoke reassuringly about progress. I believed there ought to be room in government for someone whose credentials came not from committees and endorsements but from the ordinary, sometimes exhausting business of making a living.
What I discovered was that politics had its own ideas about whose experience mattered.
The other candidates were accomplished, disciplined, and, in many cases, far better prepared than I was. I came to respect the seriousness of their campaigns, even as I began to understand how little room the process left for an amateur. At one forum, the woman who would eventually win the election, an older candidate with an impressive political résumé, made a remark about my work in the service industry that I experienced as condescending. It was the kind of small public humiliation that can pass almost unnoticed by everyone except the person receiving it. I remember feeling the heat rise in my face, followed by an anger I struggled to contain.

What made the moment particularly galling was her support from organized labor. I had assumed, perhaps naively, that unions would recognize something of their own membership in a working man running for office. Instead, I began to see the distance between the people who do the work and the institutions that speak in their name. Endorsements were negotiated, alliances maintained, political debts remembered. The workers themselves, the men and women whose hands built the city, often seemed strangely absent from the conversation.
During another debate, I listened as the same candidate described her role in bringing major transportation projects to Portland. I thought of my brothers back in the shop, men who had spent years laboring over the bridges and rail lines that politicians now invoked as evidence of their accomplishments. I knew what their days looked like, the physical demands of their work, the fatigue they carried home. I wanted to interrupt, to ask who had actually built those things, whose labor had made the achievements possible. But another candidate had warned me against making an enemy of her, and so I remained silent. I have thought about that silence more often than I have thought about losing.
Perhaps it was a mistake. Perhaps it was restraint. Politics has a way of making the distinction difficult.
I had been around the political world before, and much of what I encountered felt depressingly familiar. The language had changed, the faces were different, but the rituals of self-promotion and the careful distribution of credit remained intact. On Portland’s west side, those faces also seemed to reflect a remarkably narrow range of the city’s population. I found myself looking across rooms filled with people who spoke earnestly about inclusion while reproducing, almost unconsciously, the same social arrangements they claimed to be changing.
I had hoped to bring something different to those rooms. I spoke about kindness, about the harassment I had experienced during my years in Portland, about the occasions when speaking openly had brought consequences, including being censored on the radio. I believed those experiences might open a conversation about the distance between the city’s progressive self-image and the lives of people who did not always feel protected by it. Instead, I often encountered polite indifference. The words were heard, perhaps, but they did not seem to travel very far.
The press offered little consolation. Having worked as a journalist myself, I knew how easily a political story could harden into a familiar narrative, with certain candidates assigned significance and others relegated to the margins. I watched that process from the other side of the notebook and found it no more appealing. Reporters appeared to have decided what kind of election this was going to be, and a late-arriving service worker with an unconventional campaign did not fit comfortably into the story they were telling.
In the end, I received nearly 800 votes. It was not enough to win, or even to come close, but it was more than I had expected from a campaign conducted largely around my regular work schedule. I had continued going to my job, paying my bills, and living my life, declining to turn every conversation into a request for money. There was a certain dignity in that choice, or so I told myself. What I failed to appreciate was that fundraising had become one of the principal measures by which a candidacy was judged.
The irony was difficult to ignore. In a political culture that regularly condemned the influence of money, the ability to raise it remained a powerful indicator of legitimacy. Candidates with substantial financial support were treated as serious contenders, while those without it struggled for attention, regardless of what they had to say. I was equally troubled by the city’s use of public funds to subsidize campaigns at a time when municipal departments were facing budget cuts. Perhaps there were sound arguments for the system, but from where I stood, the contradictions were impossible to miss.
There were smaller revelations, too, some of them more personal than political. Friends I had expected to help disappeared into their own lives, offering encouragement but little else. Others surprised me with their generosity, giving time, advice, and support without being asked. Campaigns have a way of stripping relationships of their comfortable ambiguities. You learn who will stand beside you when there is nothing obvious to gain, and who prefers to admire your courage from a safe distance. I came away with fewer illusions, which is not necessarily the same thing as having fewer friends.
I do not regret running. For a brief period, I stepped outside the familiar boundaries of my life and tested an idea that had been troubling me for years: that if I wanted my circumstances to change, I might have to become an agent of that change myself. The campaign gave me an education no amount of reading or political commentary could have provided. I saw the machinery up close, its strengths and its absurdities, the sincere idealism of some participants and the calculations of others. I also saw how difficult it is to challenge a system while attempting to gain admission to it.
The election reaffirmed Portland’s commitment to a broadly progressive approach to government, much of which I continue to support. But I left with a sharpened suspicion of political orthodoxies, whatever language they use to describe themselves. No ideology possesses a monopoly on virtue, and no system is immune to the temptations of power, favoritism, or self-preservation. I had entered the race believing that some of the city’s problems could be addressed by better leadership. I emerged wondering whether the habits that produced those problems were more deeply embedded than I had understood.
And then there was the city itself.
Portland had once seemed to me a place of unusual possibility, a city whose eccentricities were part of its charm and whose imperfections could be forgiven because they existed alongside a genuine spirit of invention. There had been a time when the streets felt alive with that possibility, when neighborhoods seemed to be discovering themselves, when the city’s confidence was infectious rather than defensive. I do not know exactly when that feeling began to disappear. Cities rarely lose their character all at once. The change happens gradually, through a succession of small disappointments, until one day you find yourself looking at familiar streets and wondering what happened to the place you remember.
Perhaps some of this is age. I am not getting younger, and the patience I once had for waiting out a city’s difficult periods has begun to diminish. I have reached a point in my working life where the possibilities for advancement seem increasingly limited, and I am no longer certain that Portland’s recovery, however it eventually unfolds, will happen on a timetable that has much to do with my own. I can imagine the city finding its way again. What I find harder to imagine is myself spending another decade waiting for it.
David and I agreed that our new home would be temporary. One year, we told each other, enough time to settle ourselves, take stock, and decide what comes next. It was an oddly comforting arrangement, a lease with an expiration date and, beneath it, the suggestion that our lives might still contain an unexpected turn. Somewhere beyond Portland there are cities we have not lived in, streets we have not walked, mornings that have nothing to do with the disappointments we have accumulated here.
For now, I am still sitting on the box. The rooms are unfamiliar, and the work of making them ours has barely begun. Across the river lies the city I tried, in my small way, to change, a place I have loved and resented, defended and criticized, sometimes in the same breath. I do not know whether we will leave it for good or whether this restlessness is simply another expression of the affection I have never quite managed to relinquish.
The box beneath me will eventually be unpacked. The furniture will find its place, the walls will acquire pictures, and the unfamiliar rooms will begin to hold the ordinary evidence of our lives. But I suspect the question that followed us across the river will remain long after the last piece of packing tape has been thrown away.
At what point does a place stop being home? And how do you know when it is time to go?










See What Readers Have to Say